3 Minute Message - 01/28/2015



Recently, I received a letter from William E. Smith, P.E., a consulting civil engineer from the state of Montana, who had been studying the recently released report, "An Analysis of A Transfer of Federal Lands to the State of Utah." I asked him if he would allow me to share his insights with all of you and he generously agreed.

People from all professions and walks of life are seeing the importance of turning over our public lands to the states whose borders wherein they lie. It is crucial to their preservation...and ours.


I downloaded and began reading the report entitled "An Analysis of A Transfer of Federal Lands to the State of Utah", dated November 2014. As a consulting Professional Civil Engineer with years of experience working with private landowners on the health of their forests, and a trained wildfire behavior analyst, I want to reinforce several points that stand out to me from the outset.

The best approach toward reducing costs of fire suppression is to reduce the probability of devastating crown fire. This begins with proper management (logging/timber harvesting) to reduce basal area of trees. Forest management includes selective thinning (depending upon species and terrain), clear cutting and replanting to significantly reduce forest density. Reducing forest density increases the spacing between individual trees which directly reduces the occurrence of high intensity wildfires and increases the health and vitality of remaining trees. In addition, strong trees that are not required to over compete for limited resources are more resistant to invasion by insects.

The federal agencies, i.e. US Forest Service and BLM, cannot implement recognized mitigation and forest management techniques because they are too restricted by environmental organizations through the lawsuits filed in federal courts. To many people the forests have become sacrosanct. Even when the knowledgeable people on the ground see the need to log and salvage, they are frustrated by the system from being able to implement necessary solutions.

In addition, fighting large forest fires has become big business. In today's world, the national forests have become a financial drain on resources instead of being an agricultural resource.

Changing public opinion requires changing this culture and positively influencing many people who make their living off the current situation with public lands under federal ownership. Facts raised in the report help to make a strong case toward individual states being capable of doing a much better management job with public lands than the Federal Government.

I support the efforts of western states to acquire ownership of federally owned lands within their borders. Many people need an opportunity to be presented with the benefits in state ownership of public lands. The truth and the facts play an important part in outreach.

All the Best,

William E. Smith, P.E.

Emigrant, Montana

Please stand up and encourage your elected officials to support the Transfer of Public Lands. Many states are currently int he midst of their legislative sessions with bills that will affect the health, access, and productivity of the lands within your state. Let your representatives know that this is one of the most important subjects of legislation they could deal with. And let them know that you have their back.

American Lands Council


Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.